In August 1976, the St. Clair County Prosecutor’s Office wanted to wait on a warrant for Francis Shelden. The man running that office was on the ballot. The county’s own canvass books show what happened next: he won in November, and the warrant was authorized 22 days later.
Peter E. Deegan, the Republican Prosecuting Attorney of St. Clair County, was running for reelection during the months his office held back the warrant for North Fox Island owner Francis Shelden. The county canvass shows Deegan beat Democrat John Cummings 26,154 to 20,598 on November 2, 1976. The Shelden warrant was authorized on November 24, 1976, 114 days after the case file entry saying the prosecutor wanted to wait.
By then Shelden was gone. He had signed a trust in Antigua on September 28, 1976. In February 1977, Deegan wrote to the FBI that Shelden “fled before he could be arrested and arraigned.” Shelden died in Amsterdam in 1996 without ever facing a Michigan courtroom. Deegan went on to 30 years on the circuit bench.
Was Deegan on the ballot while the Shelden warrant was on hold?
Yes. He was unopposed in the August 3, 1976 Republican primary and beat Democrat John Cummings in the November 2 general election.
What reason did his office give for waiting?
The August 2 entry says it wanted to wait until the investigation was completed. The September 27 entry on Grossman cites workload.
Why would a prosecutor wait?
Four realistic explanations: building the case, waiting on other counties, caution around a wealthy defendant, or politics. Each leaves a different trail in the State Police file for fall 1976.
Where was Shelden while the warrant waited?
Signing a trust in Antigua on September 28, 1976, according to the Sixth Circuit. He never came back.
What happened to Deegan?
He became a 31st Circuit Court judge in St. Clair County after the 1980 election and served until 2011.
What Came in the Mail
I asked St. Clair County for Peter Deegan’s election history. What came back this week was 19 pages of canvass books and state vote statements: handwritten precinct tallies from 1974 and 1976 in a Kalamazoo-made “Kazoo” canvass ledger, a typed 1980 statement, and computer printouts from 1986 through 2004. The county also sent the state’s retention schedule for election documents, which says canvass results are kept for 100 years and then go to the Archives of Michigan. Translation: the paper exists, and it is not going anywhere.
I wanted the ballot history because Deegan’s name sits in the middle of the North Fox Island warrant delay, and nobody had ever lined his campaign calendar up against his case file. Let’s be honest about why that matters. A prosecutor is an elected politician. In 1976, this one was a politician with a contested race in November and a child exploitation case on his desk naming the heir to a Grosse Pointe fortune.
So I lined it up. Here it is.
Election results (19 pages, PDF): St. Clair County canvass books for the 1974 and 1976 primaries and general elections, the 1980 County Canvassers’ Statement, and Official County Vote Totals for 1986, 1992, 1998, and 2004.
Retention schedule, copy 1 (12 pages, PDF) and copy 2 (18 pages, PDF): State of Michigan General Schedule #23 for election documents. Copy 2 includes the state’s retention guide.
The Ballot
The canvass books show Deegan on the St. Clair County ballot six times for two different offices. In 1974, he faced a Republican primary challenger for prosecutor named McColl. In the township returns produced by the county, Deegan led 2,298 to 1,841. He ran unopposed that November and drew 16,673 votes.
In 1976, the prosecutor’s office was on the ballot again. Deegan had no primary opponent on August 3. In November, he faced Democrat John Cummings, and that one was a real race.
| Election | Office | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Aug. 6, 1974 primary | Prosecuting Attorney (R) | Deegan 2,298, McColl 1,841 (township returns only; city section not produced) |
| Nov. 5, 1974 | Prosecuting Attorney | Unopposed, 16,673 |
| Aug. 3, 1976 primary | Prosecuting Attorney (R) | Unopposed |
| Nov. 2, 1976 | Prosecuting Attorney | Deegan (R) 26,154, John Cummings (D) 20,598 |
| Nov. 4, 1980 | 31st Circuit Judge | Deegan 23,010, William R. Walsh Jr. 21,955 |
| Nov. 4, 1986 | 31st Circuit Judge | Unopposed, 22,911 |
| Nov. 3, 1992 | 31st Circuit Judge | Unopposed, 40,802 |
| Nov. 3, 1998 | 31st Circuit Judge (incumbent) | Unopposed, 33,481 |
| Nov. 2, 2004 | 31st Circuit Judge (incumbent) | Unopposed, 51,459 |
The 1976 general election went 55.9 percent to 44.1 percent, a margin of 5,556 votes out of 46,752 cast. Comfortable on election night. Not the kind of number a candidate takes for granted in August.
The Case File, Against the Calendar
Gerald Richards was arrested in the North Fox Island investigation in July 1976. The lead detective went looking for a warrant for Shelden, the heir who owned the island. On August 2, 1976, the case file records the answer from the St. Clair County Prosecutor’s Office: it “wants to wait on warrant for Sheldon until invest. is completed.”
The next day was primary day. Deegan was unopposed, so the primary itself put nothing at risk. The general election was three months out.
On September 27, 1976, assistant prosecutor Robert H. Cleland was contacted about a warrant for Dyer Grossman, Shelden’s associate. The entry reads: “He has not authorized as yet due to work load.” The election was 36 days away. The next day, September 28, Shelden signed a trust in Antigua, according to the Sixth Circuit’s 1984 opinion in National Bank of Detroit v. Shelden.
On November 2, Deegan won. On November 24, according to the FBI case file, an officer “reviewed case with St. Clair Pros. PETER DEEGAN. He authorized” a warrant charging Shelden with third-degree criminal sexual conduct, signed before Judge Wilbur Hamm of the 72nd District Court in Port Huron. One hundred fourteen days after the office said it wanted to wait. Twenty-two days after the votes were counted.
“Wants to wait”
The case file records that the St. Clair County Prosecutor’s Office “wants to wait on warrant for Sheldon until invest. is completed.”
Primary day
Deegan is unopposed in the Republican primary for Prosecuting Attorney. John Cummings is unopposed on the Democratic side. The two will meet in November.
“Due to work load”
Assistant prosecutor Robert H. Cleland has not authorized a warrant for Dyer Grossman. The entry gives workload as the reason.
Shelden in Antigua
Shelden signs a trust in Antigua, according to the Sixth Circuit’s 1984 opinion in National Bank of Detroit v. Shelden.
Deegan reelected
Deegan beats Cummings 26,154 to 20,598, according to the St. Clair County canvass.
The warrant
Per the FBI case file, Deegan authorizes the Shelden warrant on third-degree criminal sexual conduct, signed before Judge Wilbur Hamm of the 72nd District Court.
“Fled before he could be arrested”
Deegan writes to the FBI in Detroit asking for a federal fleeing-felon warrant: “Defendant fled before he could be arrested and arraigned.” The federal warrant issues February 25, 1977.
Circuit bench
Deegan wins a seat on the 31st Circuit Court, beating William R. Walsh Jr. 23,010 to 21,955.
Unopposed
Deegan runs unopposed for the circuit bench in 1986, 1992, 1998, and 2004. He leaves the bench in 2011, when Michigan’s judicial age limit bars another term. Shelden died in Amsterdam in 1996.
The case file gives one reason for waiting: until the investigation was completed. Nothing in the documents reviewed shows what was completed between November 2 and November 24. So here is the question the paperwork does not answer. Why did the warrant wait until the votes were counted?
Court records, FOIA requests, research databases, document access, technology and hundreds of hours of investigation make this work possible. Clutch Confidential is how readers who value that work can help sustain it, and get more from Clutch in return.
$10/month →Who Was Running the Office
Deegan was the elected Prosecuting Attorney. Cleland was his assistant. The letterhead on Deegan’s February 8, 1977 letter to the FBI lists them both, at the same address: 289 County-City Building, Port Huron. One office. One boss. One name at the top of the ballot.
Cleland became a United States District Judge for the Eastern District of Michigan in 1990, appointed by President George H.W. Bush. Deegan took the 31st Circuit bench after the 1980 election. The two men whose names are on the 1976 warrant decisions spent the next three decades as judges.
A delay with a stated reason in August. A second delay with a different stated reason in September. An election in November. A warrant three weeks after it. A letter in February blaming the delay’s result on the man who left. Every one of those is dated, and every one of them came out of the same prosecutor’s office.
Why Wait?
That is the question everyone asks me first, and nobody in 1976 answered it on paper. There are four realistic explanations. They run from most innocent to least, and each one would leave its own trail in the documents. They can also overlap. A real reason and a convenient one can be true at the same time.
One: the office was building the case. This is the reason the case file gives. Prosecutors sometimes hold a warrant to lock down victim statements, corroborate an informant like Richards, or wait until they can charge the most serious count the evidence supports. If that is what happened, State Police supplemental reports from August through November should show new interviews and new evidence. The ending should also show a stronger charge. It does not. After 114 days of waiting “until invest. is completed,” the warrant Deegan authorized charged third-degree criminal sexual conduct.
Two: the counties were waiting on each other. The abuse alleged in this case crossed county lines: Port Huron in St. Clair County, North Fox Island in Leelanau County, and Shelden’s home in Washtenaw County. One published account of the case file describes a prosecutor in another county “waiting to see if charges were going to be brought against [him] in St. Clair County.” Leelanau County’s complaints were not signed until December 17, 1976, three weeks after St. Clair moved. If jurisdiction was the holdup, there should be letters between prosecutors’ offices showing who was waiting on whom.
Three: the office was careful because of who Shelden was. Shelden was the heir to a Grosse Pointe fortune, and that kind of family comes with lawyers. Prosecutors sometimes slow down against powerful defendants out of fear of losing, or because somebody made a phone call. That trail would look like contact from Shelden’s attorneys or family in the file. None appears in the documents reviewed for this piece.
Four: politics. A child exploitation case against a wealthy family is either a campaign gift or a campaign landmine. Sign the warrant in August, and if the target is already gone, the headline in October is “prosecutor let him get away.” Wait, and the case stays quiet until after the votes are counted. This is the one explanation that would almost never be written down. Nobody puts “hold until after November 2” in a case file. That is why the calendar is the evidence here, and why this piece asks the question instead of answering it.
The State Police file for August through November 1976 is where these four explanations get sorted. If it is full of investigative work, the first explanation holds up. If it goes quiet until the week after the election, the calendar says more than anyone in that office ever did.
What Stays Open
The 1974 prosecutor’s race is a puzzle of its own. The office was on the St. Clair ballot in 1974 and again in 1976, two years apart, and the 1974 race drew a Republican primary challenger. How Deegan first came to hold the office is not in this production. Neither are the city returns for either primary. The 1972 canvass, the Board of County Canvassers minutes from November 1976, and the full primary returns sit under the same 100-year retention rule as everything the county just sent, so those are next.
And the big one stays open too. The investigation the office said it was waiting on: what was completed, and when? If a State Police supplemental report from that fall shows new evidence landing between November 2 and November 24, I want to see it, and I will publish it. Until somebody produces it, the calendar is what we have.
Shelden never answered for North Fox. Grossman never answered. The boys taken to that island never got a courtroom. The man who decided to wait got 30 more years in public office, and for 24 of them nobody ran against him. If you have documents from the St. Clair County Prosecutor’s Office in 1976, or you remember that race, the Clutch Intel tip portal is open, and every tip gets checked against the paper.