A tractor owner can’t get the software to fix her own combine. A tenant can’t get help reading her own eviction papers from anyone without a law license. Different industries, same move: control the tools, call it safety, and send the bill to the people locked out.
Michigan’s unauthorized practice of law statute, MCL 600.916, makes it contempt of court for anyone without a Michigan law license to practice law. The Michigan Supreme Court defines practicing law as counseling or assisting someone in matters that require legal discretion and profound legal knowledge. Its stated purpose is protecting the public.
Right to repair fights follow the same structure. Manufacturers withhold parts, manuals, and diagnostic software and say it is for safety. The FTC reviewed those claims in 2021 and found little evidence behind them. The record in Michigan courts points the same way. Most people facing debt collection have no lawyer, self-help tools produce outcomes close to represented cases, and the licensed profession disciplines only a small fraction of its own. UPL should stop being used against citizens helping citizens. The law should keep its teeth for the people it was supposed to stop: impostors who claim to be lawyers and scammers who take money for help they never deliver. Everything in between should be opened up, backed by fraud enforcement and automated integrity checks.
What counts as practicing law in Michigan?
Counseling or assisting someone in matters that require legal discretion and profound legal knowledge, under Dressel v Ameribank. Filling in standard public forms generally does not count.
What happens to someone accused of UPL?
MCL 600.916 makes a violation contempt of the Michigan Supreme Court and of the circuit court where it happened. The State Bar of Michigan handles enforcement.
Why compare it to right to repair?
Both systems let you do it yourself in theory, keep the tools from you in practice, shut out independent helpers, and justify it as protecting you.
Would anyone still be stopped?
Yes. Pretending to be a lawyer and taking money for help you don’t deliver should stay illegal. What should end is treating a neighbor, an advocate, or a self-help tool as a contempt case.
Is Michigan changing anything?
Slowly. A pilot now lets trained nonlawyers sit with self-represented people in civil court, but it cannot give legal advice and leaves UPL law in place.
The Repair Shop and the Courthouse
I’ve been watching the right to repair fight for a while, and the longer I watch it, the more familiar it looks. Let me tell you what I notice.
A manufacturer sells you a machine. You own it. You are allowed to fix it. But the diagnostic software, the service manuals, and the parts are available only to authorized dealers, so the right to fix it is mostly theoretical. Independent shops that could do the work are shut out. The manufacturer says this protects you from unsafe repairs.
Now swap the machine for a lawsuit. You are allowed to represent yourself. But the knowledge of how to answer a complaint, what defenses exist, and which form goes where is reserved for licensed attorneys. A paralegal, a social worker, a nonprofit volunteer, or a software tool that could walk you through it risks a contempt charge if it goes too far. The profession says this protects you from bad legal help.
Same structure.
Same justification.
Same people left standing alone.
I am not a lawyer. Clutch Justice builds court-data and research tools, including tools that help people organize evidence for grievances, and has a stake in the question of what nonlawyers are allowed to build and offer. This piece is commentary and reporting, not legal advice.
| Question | Right to Repair | Unauthorized Practice of Law |
|---|---|---|
| Who holds the tools | Manufacturers and authorized dealers: diagnostic software, manuals, parts | Licensed attorneys: individualized legal advice and representation |
| Stated reason | Safety, security, and quality of repairs | Protection of the public, per Dressel v Ameribank |
| Doing it yourself | Allowed, without the tools to do it well | Allowed, without the help to do it well |
| Independent helpers | Independent repair shops, locked out of software | Paralegals, advocates, nonprofits, legal tech, exposed to contempt |
| What federal review found | FTC (2021): scant evidence for manufacturer justifications | No comparable federal review; Second Circuit upheld New York UPL limits on nonlawyer debt advice (2025) |
| Michigan status | SB 302 in committee since May 13, 2025; Michigan AG joined the Deere suit, settled July 8, 2026 | UPL unchanged; accompaniment pilot under AO 2025-1; paralegal pilot proposed in 2023 |
What Michigan Actually Prohibits
MCL 600.916 bars anyone not regularly licensed in Michigan from practicing law, engaging in the law business, or holding themselves out as a lawyer. It carves out a lawyer licensed elsewhere who is temporarily in Michigan on a particular matter, domestic violence victim advocates, and address confidentiality program assistants. The penalty provision is blunt: a person who violates the section “is guilty of contempt of the supreme court and of the circuit court of the county in which the violation occurred, and upon conviction is punishable as provided by law.” A companion statute, MCL 450.681, covers corporations. The State Bar of Michigan carries enforcement at the Supreme Court’s direction and has sought injunctions against violators.
The statute never defines “practice of law.” For decades the Michigan Supreme Court said a fixed definition was impossible. In 2003, in Dressel v Ameribank, it changed course. A bank had charged a $400 fee for filling in standard mortgage documents, and the borrowers sued, arguing that was unauthorized practice. The Court said it was not, and wrote this: “We hold that a person engages in the practice of law when he counsels or assists another in matters that require the use of legal discretion and profound legal knowledge.” It added that completing standard public legal forms generally is not law practice, and tied its definition to the statutes’ purpose of protecting the public.
Read that holding closely. The line turns on “legal discretion” and “profound legal knowledge,” and the people who decide where discretion begins are lawyers and judges. That is like letting the manufacturer define which repairs count as “complex.” The State Bar itself asked the Supreme Court to adopt a written court rule defining the practice of law after Dressel, arguing that a uniform definition would reduce litigation and help enforcement. The bank in Dressel won. An unlicensed person helping a neighbor answer a collection suit would be making a different bet.
Notice too that the statute does two separate things. It bans holding yourself out as a lawyer, and it bans practicing law. The first targets impostors: the person who prints “attorney” on a business card, takes a retainer, and disappears. Nobody needs that protection more than the people this article is about. The second sweeps in everyone else: the neighbor, the advocate, the volunteer, the software. That is the part that needs to stop being used against citizens.
Who Is Standing in Court Alone
The Legal Services Corporation’s 2022 Justice Gap study found that low-income Americans get no legal help, or not enough, for 92 percent of the civil legal problems that substantially affect them. Michigan’s numbers fill in the picture.
A Michigan Justice for All Commission report found that debt collection cases were 37 percent of all civil filings in the state’s district courts in 2019. Fewer than half of one percent of defendants in those cases had a lawyer. Ninety-six percent of plaintiffs did. That is not a fair fight with an occasional mismatch. It is a system where one side brings counsel and the other side, almost every time, brings a summons and a deadline.
The Commission’s 2023 report on nonlawyer legal services found that more than one in six Michiganders qualify for free legal aid, and that there is one legal aid attorney for every 5,401 of them. The State Bar’s Modest Means program, for people at or below 250 percent of the poverty line, has more demand than participating attorneys. Michigan does not guarantee counsel in most civil cases, and volunteers cannot close a gap that size.
Here is the part the gatekeeping argument has to explain. When the state gave people better tools, they used them well. An LSC-funded evaluation of Michigan Legal Help, the state’s online self-help site, looked at divorce cases. In 2013, 48 percent of Michigan divorces were filed by self-represented plaintiffs, and 42 percent had no attorney involvement at all. Litigants who used the Michigan Legal Help site obtained a judgment of divorce about 74 percent of the time, which the evaluators called virtually equal to self-represented litigants who didn’t use it and to litigants with lawyers. Self-represented litigants also finished faster.
Give people the manual and they fix the machine. Michigan already proved it in divorce court. The question is why the manual stops at the exact point where it would start to cost lawyers business.
Michigan defines the practice of law
In Dressel v Ameribank, the Michigan Supreme Court holds that a bank filling in standard mortgage forms for a fee is not practicing law, and defines practice as counseling or assisting in matters requiring legal discretion and profound legal knowledge.
The FTC tests the safety argument
A unanimous, bipartisan FTC sends Congress Nixing the Fix, its review of manufacturer repair restrictions, after a 2019 workshop and public comment.
A Michigan blueprint for paralegals
The Justice for All Commission approves a report recommending a four-year paralegal licensing pilot in debt collection, landlord-tenant, expungement, uncontested divorce, minor guardianships, and civil infractions, plus a pilot for trained “associated professionals.”
The FTC and Michigan sue Deere
The FTC and attorneys general from Michigan, Arizona, Illinois, Minnesota, and Wisconsin bring an antitrust suit alleging Deere kept its fully functional repair software for authorized dealers.
Two Michigan half-steps
Senate Bill 302, the Agricultural Equipment Repair Act, is introduced and referred to committee. Five weeks later, the Supreme Court adopts Administrative Order 2025-1, a pilot letting trained nonlawyers accompany self-represented people in civil proceedings.
Upsolve loses its injunction
The Second Circuit vacates an order that had let Upsolve’s trained nonlawyer “Justice Advocates” give free, scripted advice to New Yorkers facing debt suits. The court holds UPL rules regulate speech, but treats them as content-neutral.
The door closes twice
The federal district court in Manhattan rules against Upsolve on the merits in early March. On March 30, the U.S. Supreme Court denies review of the Second Circuit decision.
Deere opens up; Michigan opens a pilot
Deere settles with the FTC and the five states and agrees to give owners and independent shops the repair resources its authorized dealers have. In September, the Michigan Supreme Court announces registration for accompaniment providers under AO 2025-1.
The Safety Argument, Tested
Manufacturers have defended repair restrictions for decades on safety, security, and quality. In 2021 the FTC actually checked. Its report to Congress concluded that “there is scant evidence to support manufacturers’ justifications for repair restrictions.” It found no empirical evidence that independent shops were more likely than authorized ones to compromise customer data. Five years later, Deere agreed to hand owners and independent shops the same repair resources as its dealers.
The legal profession’s version of that claim has had less testing, but the tests that exist point the same direction. Utah’s Supreme Court opened a regulatory sandbox in 2020 that let nontraditional providers, including nonlawyer-owned companies and technology platforms, offer legal services under monitoring. By 2022 it had authorized 26 entities, and the court reported that its Office of Legal Services Innovation had not observed evidence of consumer harm. Authorization was contingent on that data. Arizona eliminated its ban on nonlawyer ownership and has approved more than 150 alternative business structures since 2021.
And when a legal tech company did mislead people, the existing consumer protection system handled it without a single UPL charge. The FTC charged DoNotPay, which marketed itself as “the world’s first robot lawyer,” with claiming its AI could substitute for a human lawyer without ever testing that claim. In January 2025, the Commission voted 5-0 to finalize an order requiring $193,000 in relief, notice to subscribers, and a ban on lawyer-equivalence claims without evidence. That is how fraud gets handled in every other market. Michigan’s own Consumer Protection Act was one of the claims pleaded in Dressel.
Court records, FOIA requests, research databases, document access, technology and hundreds of hours of investigation make this work possible. Clutch Confidential is how readers who value that work can help sustain it, and get more from Clutch in return.
$10/month →The License Does Not Screen Out Dishonesty
The strongest version of the UPL argument is that the license keeps dishonest people away from vulnerable ones. I want to be direct about this, because it is the claim my own experience contradicts most. The people I have watched be the most dishonest have been attorneys in positions of power. Not the paralegal. Not the advocate. Not the person at the self-help desk. Licensed lawyers, and some of them wearing robes.
A license is a gate at the entrance. It measures what someone knew on the day they passed the bar exam and the character file they had on the day they were admitted. It does not watch what happens after. Michigan’s oversight numbers show how little of that later conduct turns into public consequences.
AGC figures are from its 2023 annual report, the latest posted on its statistics page. ADB and JTC figures are from their 2024 annual reports. The AGC approved 110 individual grievances for formal complaint in 2023; one formal complaint can cover several grievances. The JTC report’s own summary chart gives slightly different counts for admonitions and cautions than its text.
Some of those dismissals are surely right. People file grievances because they lost, and the JTC says many requests ask it to act as an appeals court, which it can’t. But the system that decides which grievances have merit is staffed and governed by the same profession, and most of its work happens out of public view. Judicial Tenure Commission investigations are confidential unless it files a public complaint, and in 2024 it filed none. A license backed by that kind of oversight is not consumer protection. It is a membership card.
Michigan law treats unlicensed helpers as in contempt of the Supreme Court, while 586 of the 622 grievances against judges resolved in 2024 ended without any action.
Automation as an Integrity Tool
If the license is not what keeps people honest, something else has to. My answer is to take discretion out of the places where dishonesty hides, and replace it with systems that run the same way for everyone.
Michigan already has a working example, and it came from the lawyer side. Under the Trust Account Overdraft Notification rule, a bank must notify the Grievance Administrator automatically when an attorney overdraws a client trust account. Nobody has to decide to report it. Nobody has to be brave. In 2015, that automatic trigger generated 194 of the 2,208 grievances the Attorney Grievance Commission docketed. That is integrity by automation: a rule that fires regardless of who the lawyer is or who they know.
Michigan Legal Help is the other example. Its guided interviews turn a person’s answers into court forms, which is exactly the work the profession once called too complex for laypeople. The evaluation numbers say it works.
Build outward from those two models and the system looks different. Every court form gets a guided, plain-language version. Deadlines are calculated and sent automatically, the way a bank sends overdraft notices. Case-level outcome data, including how often each judge grants fee waivers or default judgments, is published automatically instead of by FOIA fight. Grievance and complaint dispositions are tracked and published in aggregate, so the public can see patterns that confidential files hide. Anyone who offers legal help, licensed or not, discloses who they are, what they charge, and whether they carry insurance, and answers to fraud law if they lie. That is the Deere settlement, translated: give everyone the same tools the authorized dealers have.
What Michigan Is Trying, and Where It Stops
Michigan is not standing still, but every reform so far has been built to leave the gate where it is.
The Justice for All Commission’s 2023 report recommended a four-year pilot licensing qualified paralegals for limited work in debt collection, landlord-tenant, expungement, uncontested divorce, post-judgment child support, minor guardianships, and civil infractions. Even that pilot would bar paralegals from trials, evidentiary hearings, and appeals, and would require a filed affiliation with a licensed Michigan attorney. The same report drew the line the whole system runs on: “Providing legal information is not the practice of law; giving legal advice is.”
What the Supreme Court actually adopted is narrower. Administrative Order 2025-1, adopted June 18, 2025, lets registered accompaniment providers working through nonprofit, government, or domestic violence agencies sit with a self-represented person at the litigant table, take notes, explain proceedings, and, with permission, summarize the facts and relief sought. They may not give legal advice, charge a fee, or keep going once the person gets a lawyer. The order says the services do not constitute the practice of law, and that it “does not change existing law concerning the unauthorized practice of law.” Registration opened in September 2026.
The repair side has its own version. SB 302 was introduced May 13, 2025, with bipartisan sponsors, and referred to the Senate Committee on Natural Resources and Agriculture. It would require farm equipment makers to provide repair resources, but if a manufacturer is covered by a nationwide memorandum of understanding on repair, that agreement governs instead. The Michigan Farm Bureau has said it wants those industry agreements fully implemented before a law. Meanwhile, Michigan’s Attorney General helped win a better deal from Deere in federal court than the bill would guarantee.
The Case for Keeping UPL as It Is
The other side deserves its strongest version, so here it is. Licensed lawyers owe fiduciary duties, carry confidentiality and privilege obligations, and can be disciplined or disbarred. A person harmed by a bad lawyer has a regulator and, often, a malpractice claim. Unlicensed providers may have neither. Defenders also point to Arizona, where critics including The Arizona Republic, as quoted by The Washington Times, say that “Many of the licensed companies operate more like call centers than law firms,” generating leads through advertising and parceling them out to partners in other states. And consumer advocates are not united: when Upsolve went to the Second Circuit, advocates for low-income consumers filed on opposite sides.
Those concerns are real, and every one of them is about a bad actor, not a helper. That is the line I would draw. Keep the ban on pretending to be a lawyer. Keep fraud illegal, and enforce it hard against anyone who takes money for legal help and doesn’t deliver, licensed or not; DoNotPay shows the FTC can reach them. Attach fiduciary duties, confidentiality, insurance, and disclosure to anyone who offers legal help for a fee. The lead-mill problem in Arizona is a problem of lawyer-run referral networks operating across state lines, which is an argument for transparency and outcome data, not for keeping tenants from asking a trained advocate what an eviction notice means. And a discipline system that dismisses most grievances against licensed lawyers is a weak foundation for the claim that the license is what protects the public.
Why This Matters Beyond Lawyers
The right to repair movement won ground by refusing to accept that ownership ends where the manufacturer’s business model begins. The same logic applies to a case with your name on it. It is your eviction, your debt, your custody order, your record. The law that governs it is public. The forms are public. The courtroom is public. The only thing kept private is the help.
UPL should end as a weapon against citizens and stay pointed at scammers and impostors. Here is what I would put around it. Fraud law that applies to everyone who offers legal help, licensed or not. Mandatory disclosure of who is helping you, what they charge, and what recourse you have. Public outcome data, so people can see what actually works. And automated integrity checks, built the way the trust account overdraft rule is built, that fire the same way no matter who the person is or who they know.
Michigan already handed farmers the diagnostic software. It can hand people the manual to their own case.
Continue Your Investigation
If this reporting raised more questions, use the Clutch Justice ecosystem to keep going.