The sketch was real. The chain of custody was intact. Everything turned on whose hand made it, and that question was answered by testimony rather than by anything visible on the page.
A crime scene diagram anchored the case against fourteen-year-old Davontae Sanford. In 2010 a Detroit deputy chief testified the boy drew it entirely, including where the bodies lay. During a 2016 state police reinvestigation the same official said he had drawn the scene himself, then balled up the sketch and attempted to discard it. State detectives intercepted and preserved it. Perjury charges were sought and declined one day before the limitation period expired.
Why does it matter who drew the diagram?
Because a suspect who can accurately place bodies at a scene appears to have participant knowledge. If an investigator drew the scene and the suspect only marked positions after being shown it, the drawing demonstrates nothing except that he was in a room with someone who already knew.
Is a fourteen-year-old entitled to a parent during questioning?
Practice varies and the protections are less absolute than most people assume. In this case, the record reflects extended questioning including overnight sessions without a parent or attorney present.
Why did the prosecutor decline to charge?
The stated basis was proof. Only three people witnessed the drawing: Sanford, who invoked the Fifth Amendment; the official himself, who could not be compelled; and a sergeant whose account the prosecutor concluded did not support a charge. State police disputed that characterization.
Where is the official now?
He served as police chief in Flint from 2013 until early 2016 and was later hired as a deputy chief in Highland Park. No finding of misconduct was made against him and he was never charged.
What This Case Is Actually About
Four people were killed on Runyon Street on September 17, 2007. They had been watching football. That is where any account of this case has to start, because the killings were real, the people who died had names, and nothing that follows changes what happened to them.
What follows is about a piece of paper.
Part II examined a record whose contents were supplied from outside. This installment examines something narrower and stranger. Here the document was genuine, the information on it was accurate, and the chain of custody held. The entire case rested on a question the document itself could not answer, which is who made it.
That is the second failure mode set out in Part I, and it is the one I find hardest to defend against, because there is no forensic test for authorship of a pencil drawing and no procedure that generates a record of who was holding the pen.
Twenty-Four Hours
Sanford was fourteen years old. He was developmentally impaired and blind in one eye. Police canvassing the neighborhood after the shootings encountered him outside his home, and he was taken in for questioning.
The questioning extended across more than twenty-four hours and included overnight sessions. No parent was present. No attorney was present.
He pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 37 to 90 years.
A guilty plea forecloses most of the appellate architecture that exists to test a conviction. There is no trial record of cross-examination, no preserved evidentiary objections, and no jury verdict to attack. When the case against a person is later shown to be unsound, a plea is the hardest posture from which to demonstrate it, and pleas are what the system produces when a fourteen-year-old is questioned for a day without counsel.
The Man Who Said He Did It
In 2008, within a year of Sanford’s plea, Vincent Smothers confessed to the Runyon Street killings. Smothers was a contract killer who admitted to a series of homicides. He stated that Sanford had nothing to do with it, and he maintained that position consistently afterward.
The Michigan State Police reinvestigation, completed in May 2016, resulted in warrant requests for murder charges against Smothers and another man. The Wayne County Prosecutor did not bring those charges.
So the record contains a confession from a man who says he committed the killings, a state police recommendation that he be charged, and a decision not to charge him. The killings on Runyon Street have never been adjudicated against anyone.
The Field Kit includes the Clutch Justice records request templates with jurisdiction guidance and exemption anticipation language, built for the agency reports that resolve questions like the one at the center of this case.
Open the Field KitThe Sketch
On July 13, 2010, at a hearing on Sanford’s efforts to withdraw his plea, then Assistant Chief James Tolbert testified that Sanford had drawn the crime scene sketch in its entirety, including the location of the bodies.
That testimony did specific work. A drawing produced by a fourteen-year-old showing where four people fell is evidence of participant knowledge. It is close to a confession rendered in graphite.
During the state police reinvestigation, Tolbert told detectives a different account. He said he had drawn the crime scene himself and that Sanford had drawn only the bodies.
Then, according to the investigative record, he balled up the sketch and attempted to throw it away. State police detectives intercepted him and preserved the document.
An exhibit that had helped produce a nine-year sentence was, during the investigation into how that sentence was produced, crumpled and headed for a wastebasket. It exists because two detectives happened to be watching. Nothing in the design of the process preserved it. Attention did.
The Window
What happened next is the part of this case that has received the least examination and that this installment exists to document.
On May 20, 2016, the Michigan State Police submitted a warrant request for perjury against Tolbert. Perjury carries a six-year limitation period. The testimony at issue was given on July 13, 2010.
On July 12, 2016, the Wayne County Prosecutor declined to authorize the charge. The limitation period expired the following day.
The stated basis for declining was proof. Only three people had witnessed the drawing. Sanford invoked the Fifth Amendment, because his charges could in theory be refiled and he was therefore advised not to testify. Tolbert could not be compelled to testify against himself. The third witness was a sergeant whose account the prosecutor concluded would not support the charge.
A Michigan State Police detective sergeant publicly disputed that last characterization, stating that when the sergeant was confronted with information that Tolbert had drawn the sketch, he said he did not remember who drew it.
The reason the exonerated person could not testify is that the state had not foreclosed recharging him. The wrongful conviction was therefore the mechanism that made the central witness unavailable. A person cannot both be treated as a potential defendant and be relied upon as a witness, and the office holding both of those postures was the same office.
There is a further documented discrepancy. The prosecutor stated publicly that her office learned of the alleged perjury roughly three weeks before declining. The state police report, obtained through a public records request by Michigan Public, indicates prosecutors were informed of the alleged perjury in October of the preceding year.
I am reporting that as a discrepancy between two accounts on the public record, which is what it is. I am not asserting what explains it.
Four people are shot and killed. Police canvassing the neighborhood encounter fourteen-year-old Davontae Sanford outside his home. Questioning extends beyond twenty-four hours, including overnight sessions, without a parent or attorney.
Vincent Smothers, a contract killer, confesses to the Runyon Street killings and states that Sanford was not involved. He maintains that account consistently in the years that follow.
At a hearing on Sanford’s effort to withdraw his plea, Assistant Chief James Tolbert testifies that Sanford drew the crime scene sketch in its entirety, including the location of the bodies.
According to the state police report later obtained through a public records request, prosecutors were informed of the alleged perjury at this point. The prosecutor would later state publicly that her office learned of it roughly three weeks before declining to charge.
Michigan State Police complete a yearlong reinvestigation and submit warrant requests, including perjury against Tolbert and murder charges against Smothers and another man. The report documents Tolbert’s revised account and his attempt to discard the sketch.
Sanford’s conviction is vacated and he is released after roughly nine years. Charges are dismissed.
The Wayne County Prosecutor declines to authorize perjury charges, citing the unavailability of witnesses. The six-year limitation period on the July 2010 testimony expires the next day.
What the Record Establishes and What It Does Not
I want to be careful here, because this installment names a living person in connection with alleged conduct that was never charged.
What is documented: Tolbert testified in July 2010 that Sanford drew the sketch entirely. He told state police detectives during the reinvestigation that he had drawn the scene himself. The state police sought a perjury warrant. The prosecutor declined. The limitation period expired.
What is not established: that Tolbert committed perjury. He was never charged, never tried, and no court has made any finding against him. A prosecutor’s declination is not an exoneration, and it is not a conviction either. It is an absence of adjudication, which is the same category of outcome this publication has documented repeatedly and which resolves nothing for anyone.
He went on to serve as police chief in Flint and later as a deputy chief in Highland Park.
Michigan provides no route by which a charging declination involving a law enforcement official can be reviewed by another authority. The Attorney General may act in specified circumstances or where a local prosecutor requests it, but there is no automatic referral, no independent review body, and no requirement that reasons be stated in a form anyone can test. Where the limitation period is also running, declination and expiration become the same act.
Why This Matters
The frame of this series is that chain of custody protects an item after collection and says nothing about how it came to exist. The sketch is the cleanest illustration available.
Its custody was impeccable. It was produced, retained, marked, and offered. As a physical object it did exactly what an exhibit is supposed to do.
And its entire evidentiary meaning depended on a fact the object could not carry. Paper does not record whose hand moved across it. There is no test, no log, and no procedure that generates contemporaneous documentation of authorship during an interrogation. The answer came from a witness, and when that witness gave a different answer six years later, the only remaining path to resolution ran through a criminal charge that was declined one day before it became impossible.
So the case ends where the whole series keeps ending. Something went badly wrong, an outside agency documented it, and no institution converted that documentation into a finding. Sanford was released, which matters enormously and which I do not want to minimize. The four people killed on Runyon Street still have no adjudicated account of who killed them, despite a confession and a state police recommendation to charge.
Nobody was found responsible for anything. The window closed on a Wednesday.
Part IV turns to the third failure mode, evidence that was collected and never examined. In August 2009, a prosecutor’s office official touring a Detroit police warehouse in connection with ballistics evidence noticed steel shelving stacked with white boxes and asked what was inside them. There were 11,341.
Continue Your Investigation
If this reporting raised more questions, use the Clutch Justice ecosystem to keep going.