Tamara Greene was shot to death on a Detroit street in 2003. Her detective’s notes disappeared. The squad that took over was shut down. The city destroyed emails from the months around her death. Then, in 2010, the city told a federal judge it knew who killed her. Sixteen years later, nobody has been charged.
Tamara Greene, 27, was killed in a drive-by shooting at Roselawn Street and Outer Drive in Detroit on April 30, 2003. No one has been charged. Detroit police say the case is open.
The federal court record from her children’s lawsuit documents missing case notes, erased computer files, a disbanded cold case squad, and the city’s destruction of emails from four senior officials, including then-Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick, covering August 2002 through June 2003. In 2010, city lawyers told the court police knew who killed her and that the shooter was aiming for her passenger. The courts dismissed the family’s case because they could not prove the killer would have been found but for the obstruction. The case Detroit said it had solved is still unsolved on paper.
Has anyone been charged with Tamara Greene’s murder?
No. Detroit police say the case remains open and they will investigate tips.
Is the Manoogian Mansion party connected?
The party was rumored and never proven. Investigations, including the state attorney general’s, found no evidence it happened, and the federal court found no evidence tying it to her death.
Then what is the story?
Whatever the motive, the investigation into a young mother’s murder lost its notes, its detectives, its squad, and its email trail, and the city then claimed to know the answer without ever bringing a charge.
Who do I call with a tip?
The Detroit Police Homicide Unit at (313) 596-2260 or Crime Stoppers of Michigan at 1-800-SPEAK-UP.
A Mother on Roselawn Street
Let me tell you what I notice first about this case. Tamara Greene’s name almost never appears in a sentence without a mayor’s name next to it. That has been true for 23 years. It is understandable, and it is also part of what went wrong. She was a 27-year-old mother of three. She was shot to death in her car. Her murder deserved an investigation that stood on its own, whoever her killer turned out to be.
Greene danced under the stage name Strawberry. Late on April 30, 2003, she was sitting in a car near Roselawn Street and Outer Drive on Detroit’s west side when someone opened fire. She was killed. Her passenger, Eric Mitchell, was wounded. According to the federal court’s summary of the record, no one has ever been charged.
Months earlier, rumors had spread about a wild party at the Manoogian Mansion, the mayor’s official residence, in the fall of 2002, and about a dancer being assaulted there. Greene was rumored to have performed. The party has never been proven. Then-Attorney General Mike Cox investigated and found nothing to support a crime. His explanation: “We couldn’t find a victim to establish that there was a crime.” Kilpatrick denied any party took place and denied any connection to Greene’s death. Questioned by a city attorney in 2011, he said: “Unequivocally, we never discussed Tamara Greene.”
None of that changes the basic fact. A woman was shot to death in Detroit, and the institution responsible for finding out who did it did not.
| Item | What the record shows |
|---|---|
| Victim | Tamara Greene, 27, Detroit, mother of three |
| Date | April 30, 2003 |
| Location | Roselawn Street and Outer Drive, Detroit |
| Manner | Drive-by shooting; passenger wounded |
| Agency | Detroit Police Department Homicide Unit |
| Federal case | Flagg v. City of Detroit, No. 05-cv-74253 (E.D. Mich.); 715 F.3d 165 (6th Cir. 2013) |
| City’s stated theory (2010) | Drug feud; shooter aiming for passenger; killer later said to be in prison on another case |
| Charges | None |
What Happened to the File
The most useful document in this case is not a police report. It is Chief U.S. District Judge Gerald Rosen’s November 1, 2011 opinion granting summary judgment in Flagg v. City of Detroit, the lawsuit brought on behalf of Greene’s children. Whatever its outcome, it lays out the history of the investigation as the court found it in the record.
The case went first to Homicide Squad 8, under Sgt. Marian Stevenson. In May 2003, an anonymous tip linked the killing to the rumored mansion party. Stevenson reported that her case notes were erased from her computer and backup floppy disks were taken. Notes, records of witness interviews, and a videotape of Greene’s funeral later went missing from the homicide file. According to statements cited in the appellate record, Stevenson said she became a leper in the department once she was assigned the case, and her home was later broken into.
On March 10, 2004, less than a year after the murder, the case was moved to the Cold Case Squad. Cold case units exist to work cases that have gone years without progress. A case less than a year old does not belong there. Officers who raised concerns were transferred, and in August 2005, the squad itself was disbanded.
Late in 2005, the file went to the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office, then back to Detroit police. Sgt. Michael Russell investigated from December 2007 to about September 2008. In 2009, Police Chief Warren Evans moved the case to the Violent Crimes Task Force, a multi-agency unit with the FBI, Michigan State Police, and Wayne County Sheriff’s Office. His explanation, in the Detroit Free Press: “I’m not really comfortable with why (the prior) investigation didn’t continue.” The case went out for yet another review in 2010.
In seven years, one homicide passed through a homicide squad, a cold case squad that was then shut down, a prosecutor’s office, a second detective, a federal task force, and another review. At every handoff, the file was thinner than the one before it.
The shooting
Tamara Greene is shot to death in a car. Her passenger is wounded. Homicide Squad 8 takes the case under Sgt. Marian Stevenson.
The file thins
An anonymous tip links the killing to the rumored mansion party. Stevenson reports erased case notes and taken backup disks. Witness interview records and a funeral videotape later go missing.
A ten-month-old case goes cold by assignment
The case is moved to the Cold Case Squad on March 10, 2004. Officers who raised concerns are transferred. The squad is disbanded in August 2005.
Hand to hand
The family files suit in 2005. The file goes to the Wayne County Prosecutor, back to DPD, to Sgt. Michael Russell from 2007 to 2008, and in 2009 to the Violent Crimes Task Force.
The city claims an answer
City lawyers seek to file under seal, saying police know who killed Greene and need to protect an informant. Judge Rosen refuses to seal. The filing says she died in a drug feud, shot by a man aiming for her passenger.
The lawsuit ends
Judge Rosen grants summary judgment on November 1, 2011. The Sixth Circuit affirms on April 25, 2013: the family could not show the killer would have been found but for the obstruction.
Still open
Greene’s daughter’s TikTok video reaches millions in January 2024. Detroit police say the case is open and they will investigate tips.
The Emails and the Fifth
The children’s lawsuit was filed in 2005 and argued that city officials obstructed the murder investigation, denying the family access to the courts to sue whoever killed their mother. Over six years, it produced dozens of sworn depositions, roughly 10,000 pages of police and fire documents, and more than 11 million pages of police computer files, according to Michigan Public’s reporting on the city’s argument.
It also produced two findings that matter. First, the city had destroyed emails from four former senior officials, Kilpatrick among them, covering August 2002 through June 2003, the months bracketing the rumored party and the murder. The court allowed a jury to draw an adverse inference: to presume those emails would have hurt the city. Second, when Kilpatrick invoked his Fifth Amendment right not to answer questions in deposition, the court allowed a jury to draw an adverse inference from that too.
In 2008, former Detroit homicide investigator Alvin Bowman said in a federal affidavit that he believed a Detroit police officer was involved in the killing, pointing to the number of shots that hit her and .40-caliber casings at the scene, the caliber of the department’s issued Glocks. Then-Chief Ella Bully-Cummings called his statements “reprehensible” and said he should produce evidence if he had any.
Court records, FOIA requests, research databases, document access, technology and hundreds of hours of investigation make this work possible. Clutch Confidential is how readers who value that work can help sustain it, and get more from Clutch in return.
$10/month ?The City Says It Solved It
In September 2010, as the city tried to end the lawsuit, its lawyers asked to file a motion under seal. Their reason: police knew who killed Tamara Greene and needed to protect the criminal case and an informant’s identity. Judge Rosen refused to seal it. The Detroit Free Press read the filing before it was later sealed. According to that reporting, the city said Greene was killed in a drug feud between her passenger and another man, and that the shooter had been aiming for the passenger. In 2011, Associated Press reporting stated the city’s position that her killer was in prison on an unrelated case.
The family’s attorney, Norman Yatooma, rejected it immediately: “They don’t have the murderer.” If they did, he said, the city would prove it.
In 2010, the City of Detroit stood in a federal courthouse and said, in effect, we solved it. That claim did real work for the city. It helped answer the family’s argument that the investigation had been sabotaged: how could it have been sabotaged if police knew who did it? But a claim made to win a civil case is not a criminal charge. Sixteen years later, no prosecutor has put that theory in front of a jury.
Either Detroit knew who killed Tamara Greene in 2010 and has never charged him, or Detroit told a federal judge something it could not back up. There is no version of that sentence where the city comes out clean.
To Prove the Cover-Up, Solve the Murder
Judge Rosen granted summary judgment to the city and Kilpatrick on November 1, 2011, finding a lack of evidence connecting Kilpatrick or his allies to interference with the investigation. On April 25, 2013, a Sixth Circuit panel of Judges Siler, Cole, and Sutton affirmed, in an opinion by Judge Cole. The panel’s core reason: the family could not show that Greene’s killer would have been identified and held liable if not for the alleged obstruction.
That is the legal standard for a denial-of-access-to-courts claim under the Supreme Court’s 2002 decision in Christopher v. Harbury. To win, a plaintiff has to show the obstruction cost them a real, winnable lawsuit against the actual wrongdoer. In most contexts that makes sense. In a murder cover-up case, it produces a circle. The family had to prove that, without the interference, they would have known who killed their mother. The interference is the reason they did not know.
Even with the destroyed emails, even with the adverse inferences, the case could not get past that requirement. The courts did not find Kilpatrick obstructed anything. They found the family could not meet a standard that, when the evidence of a crime is what went missing, may be nearly impossible to meet.
When the thing that disappears from a homicide file is the evidence, the law asks the family to produce the evidence anyway. The more thoroughly a file is gutted, the harder the access-to-courts claim becomes to win.
Twenty-Three Years On
The family dropped its remaining claims against Kilpatrick after the appeal. Kilpatrick was convicted on federal corruption charges in 2013, unrelated to Greene, and sentenced to 28 years. His sentence was commuted in January 2021.
In January 2024, Greene’s daughter Ashly Jackson posted a TikTok video that drew more than 4 million views. In it, she alleged that her mother had an affair with Kilpatrick and was killed by police on his behalf. No court has substantiated them, and Kilpatrick has always denied involvement in Greene’s death. Former Detroit Assistant Chief Steve Dolunt told FOX 2 he did not believe police were hired to kill her, and repeated the lead investigator’s drug-debt theory. He also acknowledged that some officers were demoted and that files went missing.
Detroit police told FOX 2 the case remains open and that the Homicide Unit will investigate any tips. In 2018, an anonymous donor offered a $100,000 reward through Crime Stoppers.
Records That Could Answer This
Much of the Flagg record was unsealed in 2012, including depositions. Several records would still move this case forward. Any Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office record of a warrant request or charging decision on the city’s 2010 theory would show whether that theory was ever submitted for charges, and why it was declined if it was. Detroit Police Department internal affairs records on the missing notes, disks, and funeral tape would show whether anyone was ever held accountable for their disappearance. And the Violent Crimes Task Force’s closing or status memo from its 2009 to 2010 review would show what a multi-agency team concluded after taking over.
Why This Matters Beyond Detroit
The obvious lesson is about evidence custody, and it is real. A homicide file should not be able to lose its notes, its interview records, and its funeral video without a single documented consequence.
The less obvious lesson is about what a city is allowed to say in court. When a government defends itself in a civil case by claiming it has solved a crime, that claim should come with an obligation: charge it, or say on the record why you can’t. Otherwise the claim becomes a tool for winning lawsuits rather than a step toward justice, and a family is left with a court ruling that says, in effect, the city knew and you couldn’t prove it didn’t.
Tamara Greene’s children were young when she died. They are adults now. Detroit has had 23 years to tell them who killed their mother in a courtroom instead of a court filing.
Contact the Detroit Police Department Homicide Unit at (313) 596-2260 or Crime Stoppers of Michigan at 1-800-SPEAK-UP about Tamara Greene. If you have records or information about another Michigan cold case, send it through the Clutch Intel Tip Portal.
Related Clutch reporting: The Leverage Ran Out: Kimberly King, Arthur Ream, and the Map He Never Drew.
Continue Your Investigation
If this reporting raised more questions, use the Clutch Justice ecosystem to keep going.