Unknown Number: The High School Catfish isn’t just a documentary about bullying. It’s about the destruction that comes when untreated trauma and mental illness twist into control, deception, and betrayal. It shows how the darkest dangers sometimes don’t come from strangers, but from within the home itself.
The Story That Shook Beal City
Lauryn Licari, 13, and her boyfriend Owen McKenny endured over a year of anonymous, vicious text harassment—threats, humiliation, and emotional torture from an “unknown number.” For months, suspicion fell on peers, classmates, even close friends.
Entire circles fractured under the weight of false accusations.
And then came the biggest gut punch: the “catfish” wasn’t a jealous teenager; It was Lauryn’s own mother, Kendra Licari, using spoofing apps and fake accounts to manipulate her daughter’s reality.
Spoofing Apps and Fake Accounts ALWAYS Catch Up To You
Spoofing apps are a nightmare for harassment cases. They give harassers the illusion that they can call, text, or stalk without being traced. Victims often see only “Unknown Number” or a fake local area code pop up, making it feel like accountability is impossible.
But here’s the truth: spoofing is a false sense of security.
Law enforcement has access to powerful digital forensics tools at its disposal. Investigators can cut through the smoke and mirrors; whether it’s analyzing call records, tracking device fingerprints, or digging into app data. None of that data is out of reach, especially when all of us are constantly generating it through our phones.
Even you reading this article right now, creates a fingerprint on your phone and in my website visitor logs. Think of the Internet as a ledger; it’s always keeping a tab.
So for would-be harassers, hiding behind a spoofing app or burner phone these days is like putting on a paper mask in a thunderstorm: first off, it’s stupid. But it’s flimsy, temporary, and bound to fall apart under scrutiny. And for victims, it’s a reminder that the “unknown” isn’t always unknowable.
What cracks me up is that Kendra was allegedly an IT professional and didn’t know any of this. No wonder she didn’t stay in that IT Job. Everything you do is traceable. Period.
The much harder facet to all of this, though, is mental health.
The Mental Health Angle
The case exemplifies how mental illness can manifest in deeply destructive ways:
- Unhealed Trauma: Kendra admitted unresolved pain from her own teenage rape. That trauma mutated into rage and control.
- Compulsive Deception: What began as anonymous messages spiraled into an all-consuming campaign—hours spent creating identities, weaving lies, sustaining paranoia.
- Betrayal as Abuse: The worst wound wasn’t digital. It was psychological; the betrayal of a daughter by her mother, trust weaponized into terror.
And Then There’s The Collective Trauma
The fallout for stalking and harassment always ripples far beyond one single household, especially if there is more than one victim.
Lauryn carries the scars of betrayal, unable to trust the one person who should have been her protector. Owen lives with the confusion of being targeted and manipulated during formative years. Peers falsely implicated in the harassment suffered stigma and social destruction.
This is a community reeling from a predator hiding in plain sight, and a reminder that untreated mental illness doesn’t just harm the individual, it bleeds outward, shattering everyone in its blast radius.
The Takeaway, Is This.
Unknown Number forces us to confront two truths:
1. Technology inevitably amplifies pathology. Anonymity, spoofing apps, and digital tools made it easier to escalate harm. Even without anonymity, I can tell you that I’ve heard some truly horrible stories of, and been subjected to, online stalking.
2. Mental illness untreated is never just private. It becomes public, harmful, and devastating when left unchecked.
At the end of the day, this documentary isn’t about one “bad mom.”
It’s about the urgent need to address mental health crises before they metastasize into horror stories, to encourage people to tackle their trauma rather than let it fester. And more importantly, the absolute necessity in creating safeguards for teens navigating online life capable of stopping relentless predators in their tracks.
🖤 Love what we do? Support Clutch.
