Broken Play · Case No. 06

Robert Anderson treated University of Michigan athletes and students for nearly four decades. An independent report counted at least 20 times someone told the university about him.

Direct Answer

Robert Anderson worked at the University of Michigan for nearly four decades, including as a team physician for athletics. A 2021 independent report by the law firm WilmerHale found at least 20 occasions on which people told university staff about his conduct, going back to 1975. In January 2022 the university agreed to a $490 million settlement shared by 1,050 people. Anderson died in 2008. No criminal charges against him have been reported.

Key Points

WilmerHale, retained by the university, released its findings in May 2021 and counted at least 20 occasions on which someone spoke with university staff about Anderson.

In 1975, wrestler Tad DeLuca wrote a 10-page letter to coach Bill Johannesen. No action was taken.

Thomas Easthope, who supervised the University Health Service, heard complaints in the late 1970s and early 1980s and did not tell local authorities. Anderson left the health service directorship but was working in athletics by 1981.

Former football players have said they told coach Bo Schembechler in the 1970s. Matt Schembechler, Bo’s son, has said he told his father as well.

The university agreed to a $490 million settlement on January 19, 2022, shared by 1,050 people. A 2018 letter to athletic director Warde Manuel prompted a police investigation.

Quick FAQs

How many times was the University of Michigan told about Robert Anderson?

The WilmerHale report found at least 20 occasions on which people spoke with university staff about him.

How large was the Michigan settlement?

The university agreed to $490 million in January 2022, shared by 1,050 people.

Was Robert Anderson ever criminally charged?

No criminal charges against him have been reported. He died in 2008, ten years before the 2018 letter that prompted a police investigation.

Who commissioned the independent report?

The University of Michigan retained WilmerHale to investigate and released the findings in May 2021.

A Career Measured in Decades

Anderson worked at the University of Michigan across a career of 37 years. He served as director of the University Health Service and as a physician to athletic teams, and he conducted physicals for pilots who needed aviation medical certification. The WilmerHale report said he had countless occasions with patients over that span.

The question for this series is what the institution did with what it was told.

1975: A Letter to a Coach

In 1975, Tad DeLuca, a wrestler, wrote a 10-page letter to coach Bill Johannesen about Anderson. No action was taken. When DeLuca wrote again in 2018, this time to athletic director Warde Manuel, a police investigation followed. Forty-three years separate the two letters.

Moved, Not Removed

Easthope supervised the health service and heard complaints in the late 1970s and early 1980s. He did not tell local authorities. Anderson stopped being health service director, and by 1981 he was working in the athletic department.

The athletic department record is where the report and the survivors’ accounts converge. Former football players have said they told Bo Schembechler about Anderson in the 1970s, and one has said he was told to toughen up. Matt Schembechler has said he told his father. Athletes said athletic director Don Canham was informed and took no action. Schembechler died in 2006 and Canham in 2005.

Institutional Finding

The WilmerHale count of at least 20 occasions means the information reached the institution repeatedly. It reached coaches, a health service supervisor and athletic administrators. What stopped was the next step each time.

Clutch Confidential
Clutch is free to read. It isn’t free to produce.

Court records, FOIA requests, research databases, document access, technology and hundreds of hours of investigation make this work possible. Clutch Confidential is how readers who value that work can help sustain it, and get more from Clutch in return.

$10/month ?

2018 to 2022: The Letter, the Report, the Settlement

DeLuca’s 2018 letter to Manuel led to a police investigation. Anderson was by then ten years dead. The university commissioned WilmerHale and released its findings in May 2021. On January 19, 2022, the university announced a $490 million settlement, to be shared by 1,050 people. A settlement of that size does not prove a legal finding. It does set the price the institution put on the record.

1975DeLuca writes a 10-page letter to coach Johannesen; no action
Late 1970s to early 1980sHealth service supervisor Easthope hears complaints; local authorities not told
By 1981Anderson working in the athletic department
2008Anderson dies
2018DeLuca writes to Warde Manuel; police investigation opens
May 2021WilmerHale findings released
January 19, 2022$490 million settlement announced; 1,050 people share it

Timeline Explorer: Forty-Three Years Between Two Letters

1975

The First Letter

A wrestler writes 10 pages to his coach about Anderson. No action is taken.

Gap Flagged

The institution had written notice nearly half a century before the settlement.

Late 1970s to 1981

Complaints and a Transfer

The health service supervisor hears complaints and does not notify local authorities. Anderson leaves the directorship and is working in athletics by 1981.

2008

Anderson Dies

Anderson dies without having been criminally charged.

2018

The Second Letter

DeLuca writes to athletic director Warde Manuel. A police investigation follows.

May 2021 to January 2022

Report and Settlement

WilmerHale releases its findings in May 2021, counting at least 20 occasions of notice. The university announces a $490 million settlement on January 19, 2022.

On the Record

Twenty occasions of notice across decades is a pattern of the institution, not a lapse by one person.

20+Occasions on which people told university staff, per WilmerHale
1,050People sharing the settlement
$490MSettlement announced in January 2022

Why This Case Matters

Penn State is a case about a decision made in a room. Michigan is a case about a decision made over and over, by different people in different offices across different decades, with the same result. That is harder to fix, because there is no single meeting to point to and no single memo to cite. The accountability mechanism that normally covers a case like this, a criminal prosecution, was unavailable by the time the institution’s own investigation began.

What remains is the record. Twenty occasions. A health service that moved a physician into athletics. A coach who, athletes say, was told. The university’s own law firm wrote it down.

Investigation Scorecard

University Health Service supervision
F
Athletic department response
F
2021 independent review
B
Criminal accountability
D

The institution documented its own failure thoroughly, forty-six years after the first letter.

Sources

Independent ReportContemporary PressSettlement Record

WilmerHale, independent report to the University of Michigan on Robert E. Anderson (May 2021).

Associated Press, reporting on the $490 million settlement and the WilmerHale findings (January 19, 2022).

Citing This Article

Bluebook: Williams, Rita. Broken Play: Twenty Times Someone Was Told, Clutch Justice (Oct. 28, 2026), https://clutchjustice.com/2026/10/28/michigan-robert-anderson-broken-play-06/.

APA 7: Williams, R. (2026, October 28). Broken play: Twenty times someone was told. Clutch Justice. https://clutchjustice.com/2026/10/28/michigan-robert-anderson-broken-play-06/

MLA 9: Williams, Rita. “Broken Play: Twenty Times Someone Was Told.” Clutch Justice, 28 Oct. 2026, clutchjustice.com/2026/10/28/michigan-robert-anderson-broken-play-06/.

Chicago: Williams, Rita. “Broken Play: Twenty Times Someone Was Told.” Clutch Justice, October 28, 2026. https://clutchjustice.com/2026/10/28/michigan-robert-anderson-broken-play-06/.