Too many lawmakers love to talk tough on crime from the safety of their air-conditioned offices but they’ve never stepped foot inside the prisons and jails they keep funding and expanding.
They claim to love apple pie, America, and the Constitution, but systematically deny people their rights.
They pass sentencing laws that lengthen people’s time behind bars.
They debate “reform” bills that tinker at the edges of our carceral system.
And they do it all without ever hearing the cold steel doors slam shut behind them or seeing mold creeping up the walls of a cell block that hasn’t seen repairs in decades.
That’s a big problem.
Why? Because Policy Without Proximity Is Dangerous.
Unless you are currently or previously systems-impacted, you shouldn’t get to vote on whether to lock people up for life without ever looking those people in the eye.
You shouldn’t get to decide how much money a prison gets for healthcare or mental health without seeing the prison medical wing that’s running on duct tape and prayers.
The disconnect is palpable. We hear it in committee hearings and press conferences: politicians speak in statistics, but rarely lived reality.
The President of the United States was convicted of 34 felonies; his power and privilege prevented him from ever seeing time behind bars. Those who support him often engage in Olympic-level mental acrobatics to ignore this.
Instead, they use words like “deterrence” and “rehabilitation” like they’re abstract theories instead of daily life-or-death struggles for the people living behind those walls.
A Tour Should Be the Bare Minimum
If you’re in charge of sentencing laws, you should be required (not just invited) to visit:
- A prison unit during lockdown in the summer, when the AC is either nonexistent or broken and temperatures climb past 100 degrees.
- A solitary confinement wing, where people spend 23 hours a day alone with their thoughts.
- A visitation room, to look families in the face; the mothers, fathers, and children who pay the hidden cost of mass incarceration.
Imagine how different our policy debates would be if lawmakers had to bear witness to the mold, the overcrowding, the heat, the despair.
Maybe then they’d think twice before signing another bill that adds years to a sentence or guts funding for re-entry programs.
Proximity Sparks Accountability
Politicians are quick to tour a shiny new facility when there’s a ribbon cutting and a photo op but they rarely visit the places they’ve condemned people to for decades.
They should be required to see the cells, the chow halls, the yards. They should listen to the people they govern and deny the right to vote, not just the wardens and contractors who profit from incarceration.
True criminal justice reform requires more than fancy policy language; it demands moral courage and a willingness to see the truth up close.
If you can’t face the conditions you’re voting to maintain or expand then I have news for you: you have no business voting at all.
What’s Next
The next time a politician says they’re “tough on crime,” ask them:
- When’s the last time you visited a prison or jail in your district?
- Do you know what conditions are like for the people you keep there?
- Will you listen to incarcerated people and their families before you make decisions about their lives?
They should have to stand inside the places their policies built. Maybe then, they’d finally feel the urgency to tear this system down and build something more humane in its place.
