Beyond Michigan · Sigrid Stevenson Case Library
Who’s Who: Sigrid Stevenson

Sigrid and the people who loved her, the persons of interest investigators have described, the officer who found her, the medical examiner, and the officials and record-keepers who shape what the public knows about the 1977 Kendall Hall murder. Select any name for detail, open questions, and sources.

Clutch Justice · Compiled by Rita Williams · Last updated October 2026
Editorial standard Sigrid comes first, by name, because the case is about her. Persons of interest appear by role because no public record names them, and every one of them is presumed innocent. Officials and investigators appear for their documented roles only. Each entry ends with its sources, and many end with the question the public record still cannot answer.
01Sigrid and the People Who Loved Her
Sigrid Miller Stevenson25, graduate student, Trenton State CollegeVictim

Born January 24, 1952, and raised in Livermore, California, where she played piano from childhood. Friends and family called her Ziggy. She came to Trenton State to study music and education so she could teach. She spent the summer of 1977 traveling through Nova Scotia, selling sketches of cityscapes to stretch her budget.

Locked out of her lodging when she returned to campus, she slept on the green room couch in Kendall Hall. She was found on the main stage at 11:29 p.m. on September 4, 1977. Her murder has never been solved.

Sources: TCNJ News, Sept. 10, 2024; The Signal, Mar. 27, 2021; Netflix Tudum, July 31, 2024; Kokotajlo report No. 77-476.

Peter Cooper StevensonHer fatherFamily

Taught at Princeton University before the family moved west. He died in 1979, two years after his daughter. TCNJ’s campus police chief later said both of her parents died without learning who killed her.

Sources: Find a Grave memorial, as indexed by Trace Evidence; The Signal, Mar. 27, 2021.

Carol EdsonFamily friendFamily

Described for Netflix how a completely different side of Sigrid came out when she sat down at a piano.

Source: Netflix Tudum, July 31, 2024.

Denise FanelliTrenton State freshman, fall 1977Witness to the era

In a 2016 letter to the Courier-Post, she remembered the Trentonian headlining a campus of fear while, on campus, the subject was almost verboten under the administration. She called the ghost story an insult to Sigrid’s dignity and asked the college for a garden, a tree, or a music scholarship in her name.

Source: Denise Fanelli, letter, Courier-Post, Nov. 12, 2016, via Newspapers.com.

02Persons of Interest

No one has been charged in Sigrid’s murder. The people below are described by role, because no public record names them. Each is presumed innocent. Their inclusion reflects how investigators and published accounts have described them, not a finding of guilt.

“Chuck”Cast member, J.B. production, September 1977Person of interestExcluded by DNA

Woke Sigrid in the green room around 7 p.m. on September 3, talked with her, and gave her a beer. A playbill found among her things had his name circled with a note calling him a nice man who gave her a beer. He played a police officer in the show, so his costume would have included a nightstick and handcuffs.

He passed a polygraph in 1977. Years later, a former girlfriend told investigators he once said he had committed a murder. He died in 2016, and DNA testing did not link him to the scene.

Open question: What was compared, from which item, and does the same profile appear on anything else from the stage?

Source: Netflix Tudum, July 31, 2024.

The lighting technicianCrew, J.B. productionPerson of interestNever charged

Worked on the September 3 production, had a key to the building, and knew how to run the theater’s lighting system. Investigators believe the lights were on during the attack. When Kokotajlo arrived, only emergency lights were lit. Ewing Detective Julia Caldwell later focused on him as one of two men with keys.

Open question: Who turned the stage lights off, and when?

Sources: Netflix Tudum, July 31, 2024; Woman and Home, Aug. 2024; Kokotajlo report No. 77-476.

The maintenance workerCollege employeePerson of interestNever charged

Had a key to the building and worked in another building Sigrid often visited. She had his address and phone number, and the two were reportedly seen together. He was fired soon after the murder and, according to Netflix, was never polygraphed.

Open question: Why was the college employee fired rather than tested, and who made that decision?

Source: Netflix Tudum, July 31, 2024.

The campus security officerTrenton State campus policePerson of interestNever charged

Months after the murder, he reportedly told a colleague he had killed Sigrid. Further investigation produced nothing conclusive. He has never been publicly named, and no published record says whether the remark was a confession, a boast, or something else. He is a different officer from Thomas Kokotajlo.

Open question: Who heard the statement, who investigated it, whether he was polygraphed before or after, and how it was closed.

Source: Netflix Tudum, July 31, 2024.

The man she argued withIdentity unknownUnidentified

After the first act of J.B. on September 3, Sigrid seemed upbeat. Later her mood dropped, and she told a cast member she had argued with a man and lost. He has never been identified.

Open question: Did anyone in the cast or crew see who she was talking to that night?

Sources: Netflix Tudum; Princeton Info, Nov. 13, 2024; Solve the Case timeline.

03Who Found Her, and the 1977 Investigation
Ptl. Thomas M. KokotajloCampus patrolman, Trenton State CollegeFirst on scene

Spotted a girl’s bicycle cabled to the railing at Kendall Hall’s side entrance at 11:29 p.m. on September 4, unlocked the side door, and found Sigrid on the main stage under white material. He wrote that her wrist was cold and stiff. He then opened the rear loading door by removing its padlock and stayed crouched there, 10 to 15 feet from her, until help arrived. He appears in the 2024 Unsolved Mysteries episode. He is not named as a suspect in any source.

Open question: Was the loading door padlock locked when he reached it, and if so, how did he open it?

Sources: Trenton State College Investigation Report No. 77-476, Sept. 5, 1977; Netflix Tudum.

Sgt. HolmesCampus police sergeantResponder

Kokotajlo radioed him after finding Sigrid. He was the first to arrive, ahead of Ewing officers. A search of the building found no one.

Source: Kokotajlo report No. 77-476.

Ewing Township Police DepartmentLead municipal agencyInvestigation

Ran a joint investigation with campus police. More than 100 people were questioned and several dozen were polygraphed, including campus officers, whose handcuffs were also tested for blood. New Jersey State Police divers searched Lake Ceva for the weapon about two weeks later and found nothing. Investigators also consulted University of Pennsylvania psychologists and a psychic.

Open question: Who administered the polygraphs, and did anyone review the charts?

Sources: The Signal, Oct. 4, 2011; Netflix Tudum.

Sgt. Edward DeboskeyRetired, Ewing Police DepartmentInvestigator

Told Netflix that Sigrid had a reputation for sneaking into buildings, and that campus police had chased her out of buildings more than once.

Source: Netflix Tudum, July 31, 2024.

The cast member who saw her lastJ.B. productionWitness

Recalled seeing Sigrid around 11:30 p.m. on September 3. Her last journal entry is timed 11:43 p.m., noting the cast and crew were nearly done cleaning up. Where she was after that is unknown.

Sources: Netflix Tudum; Solve the Case timeline.

Stanley AustinMusic professor, Trenton StateDisputed account

A 1977 campus paper account placed Sigrid at his home. Netflix describes her hosts as a local fireman’s family, and Solve the Case says she never rented from Austin. He was the professor brought in to help identify her.

Sources: The Signal, Oct. 4, 2011; Netflix Tudum; Solve the Case.

04The Medical Examiner
Dr. Raafat AhmadDeputy Medical Examiner, Mercer County, 1977; later Mercer County Medical ExaminerAutopsy

Performed the autopsy, case 77-199. The one-page summary that has been published lists nine findings, including skull and facial fractures, two broken ribs, and contusions of the lung, the caecum area, and the fundus of the uterus. It has no line for sexual assault, wrist marks, or time of death. A death window of 7 to 10:30 p.m. on September 4 is attributed to her by Solve the Case.

In the 2024 Unsolved Mysteries episode, she says on camera that Sigrid was raped, contradicting the 1977 Daily News headline. In a separate 1981 Trenton death, she ruled the manner undetermined, then reviewed her own autopsy in 2002 and concluded it was a beating. That case led to a murder conviction the New Jersey Supreme Court reinstated in 2006.

Open question: What was the death window based on, and was lividity fixed at the examination?

Sources: Medical Examiner summary No. 77-199; Solve the Case; Netflix; State v. Townsend, 186 N.J. 473 (2006).

05Investigators and Officials Today
Det. Julia CaldwellEwing Police DepartmentCold case

Reopening the case, she concluded the killer knew Sigrid would be alone, knew the building, and likely had a key. She focused on the lighting technician and the maintenance worker.

Sources: Netflix Tudum; Woman and Home, Aug. 2024.

Chief Timothy GrantTCNJ Police DepartmentCampus police

Told The Signal in 2021 that Sigrid’s legacy is not the ghost story, and that the case was being examined with modern methods.

Source: The Signal, Mar. 27, 2021.

Officer Tiffany ReedTCNJ Police DepartmentCampus police

Transcribed Sigrid’s journal entries for the open case and described clear, careful writing.

Source: The Signal, Mar. 27, 2021.

NJ Attorney General’s Cold Case NetworkState agencyState

Formally took the case on September 17, 2024, after Ewing and TCNJ police jointly nominated it about two years earlier. Tips go to the Mercer County Homicide Task Force at (609) 989-6406.

Sources: Princeton Info, Nov. 13, 2024; unsolved.com.

President Michael BernsteinThe College of New JerseyInstitution

Announced in September 2024 that a piano practice room in the Music Building would be dedicated to Sigrid, with a plaque.

Source: TCNJ News, Sept. 10, 2024.

06The Record-Keepers
Scott NapolitanoFilmmaker and researcher, TCNJ 2006Researcher

Heard the Kendall Hall ghost story on a campus tour as a student and set out to make Sigrid a person and not just a ghost. He has worked the case for nearly twenty years, appears in the 2024 episode, and proposed the practice room that now carries her name.

Sources: Netflix Tudum; TCNJ News, Sept. 10, 2024; NJ.com, Sept. 4, 2014.

Solve the CaseNonprofit cold case platformArchive

Hosts the Kokotajlo report, the medical examiner summary, the 1977 floor plan, and the scene photographs in a public gallery, along with a case timeline and a summary of the medical findings.

Source: solvethecase.org.

Unsolved MysteriesNetflix, Volume 4, Episode 4, “Murder, Center Stage”Broadcast

Aired July 31, 2024, with Dr. Ahmad, Kokotajlo, Napolitano, and retired Ewing investigators. The companion article published the 1977 report and medical summary and reported the swab result and the DNA exclusion.

Source: Netflix Tudum, July 31, 2024.

Brianna Gunter and Rebekah SchroederReporters, The SignalPress

Gunter’s 2011 reconstruction pushed back on the ghost stories but repeated the “not sexually assaulted” claim without citing a document. Schroeder’s 2021 profile carried the campus police chief’s account of Sigrid’s journal and family.

Sources: The Signal, Oct. 4, 2011 and Mar. 27, 2021.

What this reference is not A research guide, not a set of accusations or legal findings. No one has been charged in Sigrid Stevenson’s murder. Inclusion of a person of interest reflects how investigators and published accounts describe them, and inclusion of an official reflects a documented role, not wrongdoing.

Clutch Justice · Sigrid Stevenson Case Library · Back to the library

Have information? Mercer County Homicide Task Force: (609) 989-6406. Documents, memories, or photographs for Clutch Justice: Clutch Intel tip portal. You can stay anonymous.

Last updated October 2026 · Free · No signup · Cite with attribution.